Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Review - The Conservative Soul

About a week ago, I referred to Andrew Sullivan's The Conservative Soul: How We Lost It, How to Get It Back (2006). Since I read it back then, but never reviewed it in those pre-blog days, I thought I would revisit it by writing a kind of mini-review.

Essentially, Sullivan would like to reclaim the "conservative" label from the fundamentalists who, he feels, have co-opted it in the United States under the banner of the Republican Party. To do that, he defines fundamentalism, and does so as accessibly and well as I have ever read. He's talking mainly about religious fundamentalism (I had some thoughts about other types here and here), and while I'm sure there are many who would resent the connection of Christian millennialists to Moslem Wahhabists, Sullivan provides a good case that there is a mind-set common to both communities.

And he doesn't like it one bit, not when they try to appropriate the word "conservative." How has that happened? Sullivan tells us through, primarily, two lengthy chapters dealing with sex and George W. Bush. In the end, he tells us what he thinks "conservative" means and what it implies.

It is here where the book becomes less convincing. In reading the final chapter, I came to the conclusion that Sullivan, long ago, defined himself as a conservative, and he's extremely unwilling to give that up...so much so that he takes his beliefs (most of which I agree with, by the way) and shoehorns them into the label "conservative." The problem is, most people would not define it that way, no matter how much an author might reach to do so.

I have stated before here that I consider myself a moderate Republican, tending toward the conservative, but I recognize that those vague terms have changed their meaning dramatically over the past few decades. I don't know that there is room for a moderate in today's Republican party, and, in a world in which any deviance from free-market ideology is unthinkable, I'm not sure what it means to be conservative.

Had Andrew Sullivan accepted this, that he can no longer be a conservative, the book would have been stronger. As it is, it is fascinating and worthwhile; the reader is simply unlikely to buy into his attempts to, as Humpty Dumpty said, make a word "mean just what I choose it to mean - neither more nor less."

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Fundamentalism - Part 2

Yesterday, I talked about fundamentalism as a general human phenomenon, as people try to simplify the complex by reduction. The difficulty of grasping a situation is made simple by creating rules and stories. For market fundamentalists, the basic rule is, "The market will always, in the end, create the proper incentives for human behavior, we just have to let it do its work." For the globalization advocates, it's, "Free trade is always good, it always creates a larger storehouse of wealth."

Unsurprisingly (at least to me), these simplistic nostrums come up against the real world and are found lacking. (By the way, that doesn't mean that others are better - I'm certainly not advocating that the communists or the socialists or the any other -ists had a better handle on the world - I'm saying that the complexity of the world, be it spiritual or material, doesn't yield to slogans and axioms. Those are forever, at best, very rough approximations.)

Of course, there's an appeal to simplicity. If no one understands evil or Wall Street, then we feel rootless; of course we don't understand those things, we're just regular people, but we like to think somebody somewhere understands them. So we open a book that holds the literal word of God, or we listen to the obscure commentary of an Alan Greenspan, and we believe it, because we so much want to. It's disturbing to think that things just happen, so we find justifications, or believe those who say they get it.

No field may suffer from this more than what I will broadly call the "technical world." Americans, generally, understand so little about science and technology that anyone who does has a good chance of being anointed a guru. Even the most junior programmer gets credit by the laity for having knowledge beyond what is seemingly possible.

And the technical world has been so successful financially that the "gurus" are soon extended well beyond their areas of expertise. I might ask Bill Gates how to negotiate a strangling agreement with virtually every computer manufacturer - he knows how to do that - but I'd be unlikely to ask him about the details of immigration policy (that didn't stop the United States Congress, of course). He is a former CEO of a computer software company, so it is fair to ask him about CEO issues, and about computer software issues, but, for anything outside of that, like American education policy, it is grossly naive to think that he will have anything more to contribute than anyone else. (He might, he's a smart guy, but he should be evaluated on the content of what he says, not on the simple premise that he's Bill Gates.)

For no one is this a bigger issue than Apple's Steve Jobs. He's helped to create some very successful products, and that gives him a cachet that goes beyond reason. He, to be sure, is to be admired for his accomplishments; I consider him one of the great CEOs of our time.

But, given those accomplishments, it is incumbent on us not to think that he has some magical powers, that his significance is more than it could ever possibly be. However, that hasn't stopped Josh Quittner, in the current issue of TIME, from penning a hagiography to Jobs. Working off the premise that Apple may be in serious trouble if they lose Jobs to retirement or, worse yet, to the somewhat mysterious affliction that has been plaguing him, Quittner creates a man who, seemingly, has been single-handedly responsible for transforming the horse-and-buggy world of yesteryear to our new sleek digital existence.

I don't need to go through the article point by point. Apple computers are still a niche market, having settled into a solid position, but we know they haven't taken over the world. The iPod didn't change the music industry as much as did the Internet, it was just a very canny realization of the hardware needed to take advantage. The iPhone, yet again a remarkable design artifact, is not a new category on its own.

As a CEO, Jobs' record is mixed, something that is even more true if Quittner's article is close to reality. He has left the company before, and it struggled; Jobs didn't get the right team in place to maintain the place without him. If the same is true this time, then he once again has failed miserably in the creation of a succession plan, as Greg Glockner so ably points out in his An open letter to Steve Jobs.

Quittner is exposed for what he is, a tech fundamentalist, like so many others. It's Gates, or Jobs, or Ellison, or someone else who "gets" the tech world and can be trusted on any topic in and around it. But that world is far too multi-faceted for anyone to grasp it all; remember that Bill Gates completely missed the significance of the Internet. No one has a monoply on knowledge, even if they seem to have mastered one small part of it or have made massive amounts of money. That's as crazy as believing the world began on October 23, 4004 B.C.

Friday, January 9, 2009

Fundamentalism - Part 1

This post has nothing to do with religious fundamentalism; for a solid discussion of that, see Chapter 2 of Andrew Sullivan's book, The Conservative Soul (2006). When I read that, I said, Aha, I know people like that, and that's exactly how they got there.

No, I'm writing about fundamentalism in general, a mode of thought that comes out of an inability to grasp some piece of the world as it is. The fundamentalist substitutes ritual and cant for thinking and conscience. In religion, the Bible or the Koran or the Pope is seen as inerrant, as the source of all wisdom, and the end of all wisdom.

But fundamentalism is a larger phenomenon, and affects a far greater number of us than we would suspect. We now hear about market fundamentalism, in which commentators sneer at those who believed that the free market could solve all problems, ignoring that those very commentators were on the same band wagon when the Dow was going higher and higher. For those of us who understood economics well enough to grasp the limitations of the markets and the "science" that describes those markets pretty well, it was laughable...except, as it has turned out, it's not funny at all.

And now we see, since market fundamentalism has let us down, a move to intervention fundamentalism, the idea that government money, spread liberally, will fix our problems. That this retreat to Keynesianism is every bit as much an experiment as was the freeing of our markets to do as they will is not mentioned, and won't be until it fails to produce the magical results.

Free trade has been another article of faith, one that is assumed, based on rather simplistic modeling, to represent a win-win-win-...(extend to as many parties as are involved). We have now discovered that certain groups don't benefit by free trade, especially in the nation that is a priori in the lead (that is, the U.S.). Even though we have all paid to establish the conditions that allow the resource-owners to gain from free trade, those gains are not shared, and any suggestion that they should be is greeting with horror.

Except that, as we see today, free trade and its close friend globalization can have some pretty troubling effects, and now the most ardent free traders are arguing for the rank protectionism of bailouts and guaranteed loans and public purchases of stock - but only for multinational companies that have their primary headquarters in the United States. The speed of this switch should be creating head-spinning cognitive dissonance, but that would require an economist to say that he was wrong all along, and that rarely happens.

In Part 2, I'll talk about one more form of fundamentalism - technical fundamentalism.

Friday, December 19, 2008

The gift of the magi

I have a relative who is extremely religious. By that I mean that she considers herself to be above the rest of us because she is devoutly Christian, believes in the inerrancy of the Bible, sees God as a judge and a father who has laid down rules that we must follow.

In my opinion, she has missed the point of the New Testament entirely, because she has a Church Lady-like attitude toward pretty much everyone and everything; compassion and love for her fellow man are not much to be seen. Unfortunately, her reading is not very deep (it's a strange sort of Bible study that reads the Bible over and over again...and nothing else, I think), so it's hard to actually converse with her about any of this - she quite easily falls back on "It's God's word" or some such to justify a raging intolerance.

I hasten to add that I have known people who weren't like this at all, whose faith deepened and informed their lives. Did it make them better people? Hard to say, but I do know they were far better advocates for their religion than the people who feed off their own rigidity. And you could discuss religion with those people, they welcomed the testing of their faith and, in general, accepted that there were inconsistencies and peculiarities in the Bible. They also tended to have read more than just the Good Book, because they were legitimately interested in what others had to say.

I've read rather more about religion than one might expect, but I find that a lot of the analysis veers into jargon and verbiage that is somewhat beyond the point to which I want to take it. I could gear up, move through theology textbooks and so forth, but it's not such a high priority for me that I want to do that (at least not at this point in my life).

That's why I welcome the discussion that Eric Zorn of the Chicago Tribune has been having with Richard Kieckhefer, a Northwestern University religion professor (you can read it here in Eric's blog). Essentially, the topic concerns the events immediately following the birth of Jesus:

The linear narrative of this story is that wise men from the east followed a star saying "Where is he that born King of the Jews?" King Herod gets wind of this, puts it together with some prophecy and figured this babe was in or around Bethlehem and was going to be nothing but trouble for him.

So they follow the star, they find Jesus and gift him. God then warns them in a dream not to report back to Herod and then the angel of the Lord appears in a dream and tells Joseph to flee with Mary and Jesus into Egypt, since Herod plans to kill him.

Matthew 2:16 --Then Herod, when he saw that he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth, and sent forth, and slew all the children that were in Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had diligently inquired of the wise men.

This is all pretty disturbing, and that last part doesn't show up in too many Christmas pageants. I won't spoil the way Eric lets this unfold, but the back and forth between Kieckhefer and him is fascinating, and doesn't once rely on terms like "eschatology" or "dispensationalism." (OK, we do see "theodicy," but it's well explained here.)

To me, this is the kind of conversation that is enlightening without pulling faith out of the hat to explain away the problems. If only I could break it out at Christmas dinner with my relative, but, I guarantee you, it would not be well-received. Isn't that special?

Sunday, November 30, 2008

"Good Christian"

As I have stated before, I don't like to delve into religion on this blog. I have no special expertise in this area, and there are no real truths that everyone can agree upon. Faith is faith, and should be respected as something personal.

However, I am willing to say that faith and truth have to be reconciled, that one cannot deny reality just because it seems to conflict with words in a book that may have been inspired by a deity, but were recorded by people who had an understanding only of the world that existed in their particular context. That is to say, even had God (or whatever word you may use to describe your deity or deities) spoken 4000 years ago about, say, stem-cell research or nuclear physics, it's unlikely that the scribes taking down his words could have had a frame of reference that would have allowed them to write their scriptures accurately.

The religious people I have most respected make this attempt at reconciliation, and do a good job of walking the tightrope between literal interpretation of a text and the advances we have made in understanding our world. They have accepted that their faith does not require them to ignore the body of knowledge that humans have been blessed with the ability to build.

There is another group of religionists, people who use their faith as a bludgeon against anyone who does not hew to every piece of "wisdom" they've received. I happen to have someone like this in my family, and this person is the most intolerant and rigid person I've ever met. Despite a self-professed Christianity, this person has learned nothing of the true message that Jesus expressed, one of tolerance and acceptance and love.

Based on my own experience, then, I give no special credit to someone for being openly religious, nor is that an automatic negative. Ultimately, it comes down to behavior, regardless of whether it is motivated by faith or a lack thereof.

That's why I find it more than a little offensive when some public person makes the assumption that professed faith is somehow a necessarily positive component of someone's character. Therefore, I'm growing weary of the college football announcers who say, "Bubba's not only a great linebacker, he's also a solid student, and a good Christian." I heard this again yesterday, and I always find it jarring. It doesn't seem to me that the audience should be asked to accept this equation, that all of these things are somehow the same. That a collegian is devout tells me nothing about his behavior or his moral worth, but the statement does suggest that we should credit a Christian with extra points, and there is nothing in my experience which grants that as fact.

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

Review - god is not Great

I haven't discussed my religion on this blog before, and I will not do so now - I blog about economics and politics and business, and those are contentious enough for me. Last year (2007), Christopher Hitchens, journalist and author, wrote a book called god is not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything. It's a book similar to scientist Richard Dawkins' The God Delusion.

Hitchens does not just believe that religion is wrong, as is obvious from the subtitle. He believes it to be downright dangerous:
If I cannot definitively prove that the usefulness of religion is in the past, and that its foundational books are transparent fables, and that it is a man-made imposition, and that it has been an enemy of science and inquiry, and that it has subsisted largely on lies and fears, and has been the accomplice of ignorance and guilt as well as of slavery, genocide, racism, and tyranny, I can most certainly claim that religion is now fully aware of these criticisms.
Actually, he does feel he's proven all those things. This book is, at base, a contrast of religion to civilization, with religion as the expression of backward, primitive thinking, doomed to be in eternal conflict with the humanizing forces of civilization.

I, as most of us, have known pious people whose religion preaches tolerance and love who are the least tolerant and loving people you'll ever find, and use their religion to justify their intolerance. I've also known other people whose faith informed their lives in giving and caring ways; Hitchens would say that those people could be moral without their religion, and he's right - but would they?

Sometimes faith is a matter of indoctrination, even of personal weakness. At other times, it provides a complement to life, enriching and enhancing it. You can argue whether or not it is man-made or God-granted, but, like it or not, faith's interaction with the individual is likely to be idiosyncratic, and blanket statements like "it poisons everything" are unlikely either to convince or inform.

Hitchens has not written a bad book, at least, not in the purely literary sense. It is impassioned, but also reasoned, and certainly makes one think that religious leaders have more to answer for than they have embraced. Religion, like any complex institution made up of people, can spend more time trying to maintain its sense of infallibility than it does in trying to accommodate a changing world, and that generally works out poorly.

So read this book with an open mind; if you lean toward having faith in religion, your basic tenets will likely not be challenged, but it may allow you to ask questions of the people who represent you and your deity. If you lean toward a lack of faith, the book may well reinforce your doubts (or disbelief). Either way, it will make you think about the role religion plays in the modern world, and that's a worthwhile exercise.
Clicky Web Analytics