Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts

Monday, December 14, 2009

Wait - what??

As you can see, it's been more than two months since I've blogged, and what's funny is that I really haven't missed it all that much. That said, it may be time to get out and drop a few insights on the world; also, I owe you, my readers, some promised posts (such as my guide to going Rim-River-Rim in the Grand Canyon in one day, NPS advice notwithstanding).

In my dedication to remaining logical and centrist, I'm finding plenty to criticize in the current scheme. Since I ripped conservatives pretty consistently in the runup and aftermath of the Obama election, you might think that I'd be in hog heaven right now. But I'm not, not that I expected much else (I'm actually pretty amused at the liberals who thought the system would change overnight, ignoring that Obama is a successful product of that very system, and apparently believes that tweaks are preferable to revolution).

But what really amuses me on either side of the political dichotomy is the raging inconsistency that people demonstrate. Let's just take one example from last month. Ezra Klein is a young man who writes for the Washington Post, and has taken a special interest in health care. A lot of what he writes is insightful and informative, and I recommend following him.

However, he can fall plague to the seduction of utopia. A favorite staple of people who want to advance some controversial notion is to let the states experiment with alternatives, at which point we can pick the best one for the country as a whole. This argument ignores differing situations - does the Massachusetts health care program, and we'll stipulate that it's been a success, really apply to Hawaii, Texas, and North Dakota? I can't say, but neither can anyone else.

But here's Klein on November 17:
Medicaid should be federalized, but so too should a lot more of school spending, along the line Matthew Miller has argued for. And these would both be good policies even outside of the context of state budgeting, as leaving school funding to local communities is a recipe for wild inequality and inconsistent standards, while leaving Medicaid eligibility to the states has left America with 51 different Medicaid programs with 51 different eligibility schemes and very little coherence.
I'm sorry, but why hasn't one really good Medicaid idea come to dominate others? You can't argue that the states can be used as laboratories for policy alternatives if real-world examples are hard to come by. I suspect we're seeing path dependence and special interests as impediments to change, and that's why I'm always mightily suspicious when anyone's pet theory is advanced as a candidate for dispersion. It's very possible that some new method of education, no matter how successful, will not be adopted wholesale by lesser-performing school districts. In the end, it will all come down to some kind of central coercion, and I don't have the sense that the United States is all that happy with that idea.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Norms

Drum mentions one of the real unmentioned issues in testing:
Now, the whole point of high-stakes testing is to provide us with hard, quantitative assessments of how our kids are doing. You simply can't be a believer in this stuff and not care about whether the tests are meaningful from place to place and year to year. And yet, as Bob says, this issue gets only an occasional mention each year before being quickly dropped down the memory hole until another year's test results come out and someone happens to casually mention it again. It's almost enough to make you think that a lot of these folks are more interested in using tests as a political cudgel than they are in whether kids are actually learning something. Almost.
This is such a huge issue. If you look into the literature on the subject, you'll see a lot about "objective norming" and the like. It all sounds very statistical and scientific, and it certainly generates no end of PhDs in education.

But creating tests is very hard, even in isolation. When you freight them with conveying more information than they can easily, such as allowing comparisons across space and time, you create a near-insuperable problem. Think about it: How would you create two tests in anything that are sufficiently different so as not to allow cheating, but similar enough that two different groups of students will score proportional to their "true" levels of ability?

Even if you could create tests far better than seems possible, how do you know the populations are really the same? There is an assumption that a 2008 group of 7th-graders is roughly the same as a 2009 group, but you don't know that, and you have no way to tell whether an increase in scores comes from: 1) A group that happens to be smarter; 2) A test that turned out to be easier; or 3) An actual improvement in knowledge that comes from education. (Again, the testing bodies will assert that they do have ways to correct for the first two, but I have little confidence in the fourth-decimal point precision that they assert.)

Yet, every year, the results roll out, and they're used to threaten or close schools, discipline teachers and administrators, allocate funds, and as a symbol of American pride or shame. That's putting a whole lot of weight on something that has inherent statistical problems. It's a real shame we're so uncomfortable with plus/minus, that we demand a false accuracy that alters lives.

Monday, May 11, 2009

Educational triage

It's been, hard as it is for me to believe, almost three weeks since I promised a follow-up to this post, one in which I discussed (yet again) the difficulty of waving a magic wand and creating 3,000,000 great teachers. It worked off a taxonomy created by Carol Burch at Decidedly, in a post where she abstracted out eight qualities that might be used to define quality in teaching. It was a good post, and the qualities did a fine job of covering the waterfront of the kinds of things we should want in our teachers, but I felt there were still good-sized problems:
So the initial question, how do we find people who are top-notch across the board?, morphs into, how do we manage the trade-offs that are inevitable? And that's the part that I never see discussed. The solution always comes down to: find good teachers, and break the unions so that we can get rid of bad teachers, and education will become great for every student.

We assume that the evaluation function is perfect, but let me pose it to you: how would you design an evaluation process that would tell you how well a teacher "understands students holistically"? I'm not ridiculing the concept, I'd like to see every teacher do that, I'm just wondering how we rate a teacher on it.

But, even if we somehow get past that problem, we're still left with the challenge of how we manage the reality that most teachers will come up short on one or more of those. There's some lip service paid to the idea of Great Teachers mentoring the newcomers, but I've never heard of such a system working totally well. And some of those attributes may be more genetic than malleable (I have no idea how you teach someone to build trust in others, at least not without a commitment to one-on-one instruction that is unlikely in cash-strapped school districts).
What I believe we have is a problem not of aspiration, but of possibility. We want all our schools to be great, to maximize the potential of students and thus make them happy, productive members of society, so we create policies that, were miracles to happen in execution, would get us there. If, somehow, 3,000,000 great teacher candidates were to show up, we want to have the infrastructure in place to attract and keep them in the profession, so we push for higher pay and better conditions and smaller class sizes. And, invariably, we end up disappointed, with another 25-year plan in place that "might" solve the problems, starting the cycle all over again.

As I've written before, one of the problems is that we don't set real goals for the system as a whole. We are stuck with the idea of creating "educated" humans, and we're getting pasted by other nations' systems that have far more specific goals. We come up with specific goals, not for what someone might do with that education, but for a proxy: standardized test scores. And that fails to work, so we change the proxy goals, we "get tough" on principals and teachers, and we sit back and watch the line...remain essentially flat.

Oh, we think we have goals, that of getting every student into college, get that four-year degree, jump into the middle class, but that goal is increasingly opposed to the reality of the jobs we're creating. So we pretend that we aren't putting millions of students through vocational training, that we're teaching them to "have the skills" necessary to exist in a flexible, ever-changing society, even though we can't define what those skills might be nor determine how to teach them.

One of the brilliant PR constructs of our time is the way that politicians and policy makers have found studies that purport that all student achievement is dependent on teacher quality and, to a somewhat lesser extent, administrator quality. That reductionism allows us to ignore the very real effect of home life and nutrition on the ability to educate our children, because those are problems that would require some effort on the part of those politicians. Far easier just to put it all in the hands of the teachers, then we can see the "get-tough" upper-level administrators rail at how "we won't accept excuses for failure from our teachers" (see: Michelle Rhee of D.C.).

But education is inextricably embedded within society, and trying to sever that link so the problems are easier ("if only those blasted unions would play ball, we'd have world-class schools") is a cop-out. We need to go back to the beginning, figure out what our schools are for, and create policies that have a chance of advancing the nation and its citizens.

First, we need to embrace what we used to call technical education (before that, manual arts). This is by no means a personal desire; what little shop I took was an unqualified disaster, as I firmly belonged on the academic track. But many of my fellow students did not, and would have been far better served by education that met their needs and their skills.

I don't mean that we should track kids too early, and we should still provide a basic education in everything so there's a common ground in being an American. But we already subsidize Internet service and pay for public libraries, so even the most vocational of high school graduates will have ample opportunities during his or her life to move back into a more academic existence (though I concede we'll need some social changes to overcome some of the stigma of that path).

Instead of putting every student on the same college-prep assembly line, and propping them back up when they fall off, at least until they turn 16 or 17 at which point we call them failures and let them fend for themselves, wouldn't we be better off expanding opportunities and recognizing that the real job market and personal attributes call for a larger vision as to what education should be?

But I've written about that before, so let me get to my second idea, one that I offer not in a wholly committed way, largely because it's impractical and would be seen as elitist and non-PC. But it's an idea that might serve as a bridge to help the talented while we figure out how we provide a decent education for every child, something we seem unable to do now.

It's triage, in which we save the kids who have a chance to thrive by pulling them out of the toxic school environments in which they're forced to try to get ahead. We use the same standardized tests that are failing to save education to at least save some.

Every year, we take the top X students from the tests (X would have to be determined by practical concerns and money), and take them out of their environment. Not only do we move the student to a school with good teachers and decent facilities, we move their families as well, with job opportunities and subsidized housing. The promising 7- or 8-year-old will be allowed to grow in the best environment our society can provide, and we enjoy the fringe benefit of helping entire families.

Of course there are problems with this idea, some real, some illusory. I'm going to ignore NIMBY concerns because this idea wouldn't hurt anyone - I'm not recommending wholesale demographic changes, just a sprinkling of good kids and their families throughout robust communities that can easily survive this meager effect.

A more realistic criticism is that this idea would put the youngest children in a position of being responsible for the well-being of their entire families, and I'd be daft if I didn't have some misgivings on that score. But this, and other criticisms, have to give way to the larger sense that we are failing most those who need the schools most to work, and we need to do something other than continued posturing and hearings and laws and programs that never seem to accomplish anything.

I know that, in Chicago, some might say that the public schools are already offering some of this through charter and magnet schools. But these are iterative, not transformative, steps, compounded by the practical unreality of asking schoolchildren to commute two hours each way every day to get an education that is, after all, promised to them by law and by tradition.

I doubt that anyone would take this idea seriously; the charges of racism and brain drain would be sufficient to derail it. But we have to do something, and throwing 10% more salary at teachers isn't going to cut it any more than vouchers or charters or whatever other magic beans that the educationist establishment has in its rucksack. Let me state the problem one more time: current theory suggests that the only way to give a proper education is to find 3,000,000 great teachers. Unless you have a plan to get that done, it may be time to try something else.

Note: understand I'm not saying that, were we to implement triage, we give up on certain school districts. It is simply right to provide a high-quality education to every single American child. But we can't even define "high-quality" right now, much less provide it, so we need to get off our duffs and try to help the high-potential children who, who knows, might offer the larger solutions some day.

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Fallbacks

I've written before about Decidedly, the company blog of Dwaffler, which produces decision software. Greg Glockner has ably manned the blog-writing chores for quite a while, and has now been joined by Carol A. Burch (I believe she's the CEO, but I didn't do an exhaustive search for this piece of information). Her writing is different from Greg's, but she has so far proved to be an interesting voice, and I hope that having two writers will make the posts come more frequently.

Today, Ms. Burch wrote about a New York Times feature that discussed the idea that teaching could become a "fallback" career for displaced professionals. To summarize the thoughts of the five contributors (three teachers, a professor, and an economist), anyone contemplating moving to the world of education should check it out thoroughly and shouldn't assume that they'll succeed. There may also not be as many jobs there as we commonly assume (statistics here are difficult to clarify, as some factoids will tell you that there's a shortage, others that schools are having little trouble filling positions - here's an interesting study that discusses this complex issue).

Ms. Burch helpfully abstracts out the qualities of a good teacher:
  • Has depth of subject matter knowledge
  • Has the ability to transfer knowledge
  • Has a passion for the subject matter
  • Has a passion for teaching
  • Has a demonstrated ability to build trust in others
  • Demonstrates flexibility to adapt content to the learning styles of the students
  • Engages/impassions others to want to learn subject matter
  • Understands students holistically (maturity, issues, personalities)
This is as fine a set of qualities as one could put together, and anyone with all of them would probably be pretty good at the front of the classroom. Her post goes on to point out that all of these criteria, after being ranked, should be used to evaluate prospective and existing teachers, and not to encourage people without all of them to use education as a fallback.

[A note here: something I've probably pointed out before, but Decidedly is one of the better corporate blogs I've ever read. They make decision software, and their posts usually concern making decisions, but it's never so overt as to be obnoxious - "Every school system should buy our product" - and that's quiet appreciated by this reader.]

I have no issue with Ms. Burch's conclusions, but I wish to point out the impossibility of finding the requisite number of people who fit these criteria. Remember, there are more than 3,000,000 elementary and secondary teachers in the U.S., meaning that roughly 1 out of every 70 adults has to be a teacher. Look again at the list of attributes, and ask yourself whether we're likely ever to find the needed number who fulfill all of those.

Let's take one as an example, depth of subject matter knowledge. This is very hard to measure in a meaningful way. One might think that more is better, but a knowledge of, say, differential geometry is useless in any K-12 setting. I'd be surprised if even a small fraction of people who use mathematics in their jobs retain detailed insight into the ins and outs of conic sections. There is a mismatch between the skills that one uses on the job, and what needs to be imparted to the young. (Obviously, one would expect that someone with a knowledge of higher mathematics would have an easy time reacquiring "lesser" math, and that's probably right. Still, there isn't necessarily a perfect correlation.)

We could go through each of the other seven categories and point out problems, but I'll let the reader take that on. My point is that, even if we get the weights right (we want high school math teachers to have more subject matter knowledge than a third grade teacher needs), we still have the problem that we're not going to find 3,000,000 people who score 4 or 5 (out of 5) in every one of these criteria - that's just not going to happen.

So the initial question, how do we find people who are top-notch across the board?, morphs into, how do we manage the trade-offs that are inevitable? And that's the part that I never see discussed. The solution always comes down to: find good teachers, and break the unions so that we can get rid of bad teachers, and education will become great for every student.

We assume that the evaluation function is perfect, but let me pose it to you: how would you design an evaluation process that would tell you how well a teacher "understands students holistically"? I'm not ridiculing the concept, I'd like to see every teacher do that, I'm just wondering how we rate a teacher on it.

But, even if we somehow get past that problem, we're still left with the challenge of how we manage the reality that most teachers will come up short on one or more of those. There's some lip service paid to the idea of Great Teachers mentoring the newcomers, but I've never heard of such a system working totally well. And some of those attributes may be more genetic than malleable (I have no idea how you teach someone to build trust in others, at least not without a commitment to one-on-one instruction that is unlikely in cash-strapped school districts).

I don't want to be totally negative; we should be working to upgrade our schools because it's the right thing to do (I still have reservations about upgrading the supply of graduates beyond the real demand of the economy). But we need to be realistic about the likelihood that these steps will transform our schools.

In a subsequent post, I'm going to explore a possible solution to this problem, one with no chance of being implemented, but one which would at least make explicit some of the assumptions we're glossing over in our current "fix the teacher" mentality.

[Note: I discussed some of the issues in the latter part of this post in one from last month, OK, we're saved, which talked about Obama's educational initiative. I'll just recall one thing from the President's speech that has stayed with me: "By 2016, four out of every 10 new jobs will require at least some advanced education or training." The majority of new jobs, then, won't, so what is all this upgrading for, exactly?]

Friday, April 10, 2009

Big time ballin'

Eric Zorn asks, in light of the news that the Illinois Institute of Technology is dropping varsity basketball, "Why does any college or university give scholarship money to athletes in non-revenue producing sports?" He goes on to write:
In fact, with any non-revenue sport, you can make the case that non-athletes at a college or university end up helping to pay the freight for the athletes. What's the justification for this, given the core mission of higher education?
These are good questions, but I wouldn't limit the discussion to non-revenue sports. Someone may be able to make a case that the revenues from some sports (basically, men's basketball and football) are a positive for the college, but they seem only to contribute to a gigantism of those programs (as we see with new Kentucky basketball coach John Calipari, who's going to get almost $4 million a year).

There are some interesting comments within the post, some reinforcing the Zorn opinion, others refuting it, like this one:
As a non-athlete, I disagree with the premise of EZ's argument. If athletic scholarships should only be given in revenue-producing sports, does that mean only basketball and football players (and baseball at a few schools) should benefit? This kind of thinking would screw women athletes especially. And while football and basketball programs make the money, colleges accrue a great deal of cachet competing in things like volleyball, rowing, soccer, swimming, wrestling and track.
Zorn responds:
Really? Colleges accrue "cachet" competing in volleyball etc? First, says who? And second, so what? What's the bottom-line value of having a volleyball or rowing team? How does it serve the core mission of the institution?

Does it attract a higher-caliber of student? More enrollments? Greater giving by alumni? Anything else that might attach to a school's bottom line?

Wouldn't have even tried expressing it better, but I couldn't entirely resist jumping in on the thread:
I would question the granting of money to so-called revenue-producing sports. That gets us into a difficult calculus where we try to decide which students bring in money and which do not (the perfect SAT kid beefs up the stats and attracts more top students, at least theoretically - what's the value of that?).

As for private universities, perhaps they "should receive no public funding," but they certainly do through grants and tax breaks. They have forfeited the right to do whatever they want.

Zorn goes on (and isn't it good to see a popular blogger who engages in some back-and-forth?):
Student achievement is part of the core mission of a college or university. I don't see how having a talented swimmer or juggler or foosball player or hacky-sacker or whatever necessarily advances that core mission.

Is it the building of "school community"? most sports have more participants than spectators, so money spent in that area should go not to scholarships, coaching salarie or travel, but to intramurals.

Nothing said so far persuades me that this is anything other than tradition run totally wild to the detriment of the institutions.

Who calculates what does and doesn't pay off? Why not let the schools make that calculation? If they can justify having fencing teams and golf teams and so on even in a tangential bottom-line, core mission way (that explains why it's better to invest resources there than in, say, science labs, library books, academic scholarships and so on), I'd like to hear it.

I think Zorn is dead on (except for his exclusion of revenue-producing sports; we should still ask if they serve the core missions of the institution). I've never really understood why every college, whatever the size, is compelled to offer an expensive football team. I know the arguments, in particular that it revs up the alums and their checkbooks, but I'd have a lot of respect for an institution that came out and said, "We take pride in our science and math and English graduates, we don't need to offer up five or six expensive shows every year heedless of cost."

I am a big sports fan, but that doesn't mean I can turn a blind eye to the disparity between what ought to be the objectives of an institution of higher learning and the actual practices. One hears about college presidents spending major amounts of time on NCAA investigations and "problems" with athletes, and it raises the question of how time should be allocated.

Of course, this is not a problem confined to tertiary education. Our high schools suffer from the same kind of misemphasis; even in these difficult times, no one ever seriously considers dropping or cutting back on football (at least in my area of the world), even as teachers are let go.

I know that there are benefits to team sports, at least for the relatively few who get to experience them. But it is not unfair to insist that we look at the benefits and the costs, and make these programs fit into a spectrum of activities that represent the actual purpose of what are, after all, educational institutions.


Thursday, April 9, 2009

Goodbye, middle class

From about a month ago, Mark Thoma quotes an article by Stephanie Schorow:
Dramatic shifts in the U.S. labor market in the last 25 years are relegating older workers -- even those with a college education -- to lower-wage jobs, according to a research paper by MIT Economics Professor David Autor.

This trend appears likely to steepen in the current recession, as employers accelerate the rate at which they shed nonessential positions....

As the labor market "hollows out," workers who in a previous generation would have occupied middle-skill, white-collar positions must increasingly find their fortunes elsewhere -- either in high-skill, high-education professional, technical and managerial positions, or in less-educated manual labor and in-person service jobs. Autor's data indicate that since 1980, older workers with at least some college education are increasingly doing what was once thought of as "non-college" work, i.e. non-routine, but not highly skilled jobs.

I have certainly written before that the "college premium" is on its way downward, and this research supports my contention. We need to be cognizant of the implications of this idea, because it changes many of our long-held beliefs as to how we get ahead, and calls into question the commonly-held belief that more education is always better. I just don't know what it will take to get us to see that putting every young person on the college track and letting them fail into the vital (but non-academic) jobs is not a recipe for long-term survival.

Friday, April 3, 2009

Too much book-larnin'?

In the category of late to the party, I put a reference to an excellent Vanity Fair article by the reliable Michael Lewis, Wall Street on the Tundra. It chronicles, in painful detail, the way that Iceland messed up its economy. Essentially, the country became obsessed with finance, making scores of young people into untutored investment bankers.

There's too much here to summarize properly, you really have to read it for yourself, but, for me, a telling quote:

Back away from the Icelandic economy and you can’t help but notice something really strange about it: the people have cultivated themselves to the point where they are unsuited for the work available to them. All these exquisitely schooled, sophisticated people, each and every one of whom feels special, are presented with two mainly horrible ways to earn a living: trawler fishing and aluminum smelting. There are, of course, a few jobs in Iceland that any refined, educated person might like to do. Certifying the nonexistence of elves, for instance. (“This will take at least six months—it can be very tricky.”) But not nearly so many as the place needs, given its talent for turning cod into Ph.D.’s. At the dawn of the 21st century, Icelanders were still waiting for some task more suited to their filigreed minds to turn up inside their economy so they might do it.

Enter investment banking.

I do understand that one cannot compare Iceland to the United States (though Lewis certainly finds parallels to our high-flying world of finance), but it seems indicative of something that it is at least possible for a nation to have too much education. It demonstrates that the commonly-held idea that more education is always better is false, that its truth depends on a base that is considerably more complicated.

As I have pointed out before, the labor market is in many ways not a market at all. No one really cares if everyone has an SUV, or a big-screen TV, but we want everyone to be working. The employment market really only works in two cases: either there is so much demand for everyone that the supply mix is immaterial, or the demand has to pretty closely match the supply.

I would contend that, for a very long time, the first condition was true in America (generally, that is; I'm not forgetting the Great Depression). We were so productive and had such resources that we needed everyone, no matter what they did. And as classical economics would tell you, that situation leads to incomes being bid up, and that's just what happened, from CEOs to garbage haulers.

But our growth rate, for a host of reasons, is no longer what it was, even potentially. We're not China that can unleash pent-up demand and grow in the double digits every year. We've moved to a mature phase in which growth can come only from real innovation, and that will never be 10+% again.

So our labor market is in the second situation, that is, the people we're producing have to pretty well match up to the opportunities we have. That matching has to come out of the whole system we have. If we tell our young people (as we have) that agriculture is a dead end for the uneducated, so no one enters the field, but we still need, say, 1,000,000 people to work on farms, we can only get them from two places: from somewhere else, or from those who haven't succeeded in anything else.

That is the crux of the Iceland problem, that they can't paper over the mismatch by importing workers to do the fishing and smelting. There are structural reasons, most social, why that won't work. It also is not clear, if they did import workers, what Icelanders would then do, other than leave the country.

Now I hear the objection. What should happen, if Icelanders are extremely well-educated but have nothing to do, is they should become great innovators and creators. That's the assumption our experts make, that more education will lead our youth to make the future.

That's not wholly untrue. We have a far greater ability to assemble a critical mass of diverse-skilled workers to accomplish things, much more than does Iceland. If we overeducate some number of people, there is some probability that they will find something to do, and it may even be productive and lucrative (like Twitter...but I don't want to start on that).

But some is not 100%, and, in my opinion, it is possible to have too much education, and almost certain in specific fields. Which leads us to the Iceland case, one that I think serves as a cautionary tale for us. Instead of assuming that more education in any field is absolutely required to be a good thing, we need to start looking at the mix, and, perhaps, provide incentives for young people to enter vocations that we're actually going to need. More home health care workers, fewer software engineers.

Otherwise, we're left with the argument that supply inevitably creates its own demand, and we're pretty sure that's not an inviolable law at all.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

How we can make globalization work for us

It's no secret to regular readers of this blog that I have concerns about the hidden costs of globalization. I do not, cannot, deny the positive effects of all the policies that fall within this term, but I think the standard economic model, the place where a great deal of the discussion begins and ends, is too limited to capture reality. We can draw all the graphs we want that demonstrate that two countries that engage in free trade both end up better off; the flaws come when we ignore all the constituent groups that make up a nation, and when we accept GDP as a proxy for the health of that nation.

For the average American, the picture of the "benefits" is a lot blurrier; in many cases, they've seen careers (not just "jobs") disappear, and, with them, large sections of whole cities and towns. The offshorers are doing a lot better than the offshored, as they've taken huge percentages of the gains out of the stream. Neither customers nor shareholders seem to have realized the huge benefits that have been promised; saving a buck on a sweater doesn't seem like much next to a loss of livelihood.

We have not done a good job at all of assessing these costs, as the discussions generally devolve into tiresome rants about "America First" vs. economic orthodoxy. In reality, we have no idea the extent to which American students are shying away from technology because they don't expect to find jobs in those fields. Instead, we urge them to enter those fields anyway because "that's the future."

In economics terms, we focus on expanding the supply on the questionable proposition that an increase will somehow create its own demand; we pay no attention to the reality that demand for Americans has been dropping, and we never touch on the certainty that differing wage scales may have something to do with that. Furthermore, to forestall the possibility that someone may raise such an argument, our leading offshorers and their apologists have decided to adopt the strategy of calling out American workers as stupid and incompetent, and the press has happily gone along with that.

But why should an American youngster, looking at the job market of the future, take on the challenge of a curriculum in science or technology? Your education is substandard, your work habits are terrible, you're more concerned with updating your Facebook page than doing any hard work. And the genetically-endowed, 100 hours a week young people from China and India are going to eat your lunch anyway.

Even if you are good, and hard-working, you run into another obstacle: college tuition rates seem impervious to economic reality. The Indian who attends one of the Indian Institutes of Technology (IIT) pays about $750 a year. You will pay $45,000 for a year at MIT. If the IIT Indian gets a job at $10,000, he can pay his whole tuition in under four months. The MIT grad will need a job at $600,000 to do the same. Obviously, that's unlikely, so the American will tend to start with a huge burden of debt, in fields that have uncertain prospects.

But there is an answer, and the only question I have is why it hasn't happened yet. What we need is for IIT to create a degree-granting distance learning program. Offer a B.Tech. over the Internet, and I guarantee Americans will flock to it, especially when it only costs, say, $2000 a year. (It can't be too hard for those brilliant students to set up, not if you listen to Tom Friedman or Bill Gates; it's probably no more than a weekend project for these bright-eyed geniuses.)

I'm not being sarcastic here; I honestly want to see this happen. You see, it's pretty obvious that higher education in the U.S. has turned into a scam. The economics makes no sense, with high tuition rates propped up by every expert who tells us that the key to our future is to get those degrees, and go back for more and more training, and that will make us globally competitive (despite the massive wage disparities). Let's run some numbers.

Visualize an Intro to Econ course in one of our larger universities. We see a giant amphitheater with students filling every one of the 1000 seats. At the front is an ABD (all but dissertation) lecturer who is, for all intents and purposes, a university contractor. Let's say each student pays $1000 per course they take (that's conservative). So we have a million dollars in revenue. The lecturer gets $5000 for teaching the course (that's generous), and let's multiply that by four to capture overhead, foregone tuition for the TA, and other expenses. Thus, the course costs about $20,000 to present. $1,000,000 vs. $20,000: that's pretty good profit for the school. Each student in that class is subsidizing something else (landscaping for the president's residence, the lacrosse team, and so forth).

The apologists for our university system will argue that I'm being simplistic here, that the value of a degree from the University of Podunk is far greater than simple dollars and cents. The experience, the exposure to alternative points of view, the friends that will last a lifetime.

If that's true, then existing on-line courses should be cheaper than on-campus instruction. One example: the University of Illinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science charges in-state students $5363 per semester. Their on-line students pay $1952 for 4 graduate hours. A typical load is 12 hours per semester. So on-line students actually pay about $500 more (maybe the U of I servers eat a lot).

I have to admit I'm at a loss as to why IIT hasn't set something up in the U.S. This is a huge arbitrage opportunity; they could charge three (four, five) times their normal tuition, American students would save 90-95%, and American companies would get more of these highly-coveted graduates, young people who, because they would be free of crippling student loan debt, could work for less than they possibly can now. Seems like a win-win to me.

Oh, there would be one big loser in this: the current American higher education system. One wonders how supportive our economics departments would be of free trade when their doors close because, say, Cambridge is offering degrees over the Internet ("Get your degree at the place that taught Keynes everything he knew"). They'd fight back, of course; we'd see and hear learned PhDs arguing why Internet learning is inferior, how it leads to a lack of quality, how we can't equate the on-campus experience to that on a computer screen, how we need to have an American presence in the field. You know, all the arguments they blithely ignore when confronted with them with respect to people's jobs.

One has to expect that the resistance would be keen. The supposedly-independent accreditation bodies might refuse to approve an IIT engineering curriculum. If they did that, they would be the ones called into question. After all, award-winning journalist Tom Friedman has claimed that IIT is "more selective than Harvard," so no one could argue that their program isn't up to snuff.

I'm not one to look for conspiracies everywhere. I can't seriously argue that there's some kind of collusion going on between foreign schools and our schools that prevents on-line learning from taking place. But you have to wonder when you see what would be a huge opportunity for, say, IIT to pull in some serious bucks and extend their brand, and they don't take advantage of it.

If this ever does happen, the entire field of American higher education will be rocked to the core. A system that depends on massive cross-subsidization will collapse under competitive pressures. To see a model for this, we need only look at American manufacturing, at our auto companies.

But Americans should, just once, have the chance to take advantage of offshoring in the same way that CEOs have. If that means a few free-market economists lose their jobs, well, hey, that's just the inexorable workings of the great market, and none of them, surely, could object to that.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

More on outsourcing

I don't have a lot new to contribute on this topic, largely because I don't do the tough work Citizen Carrie does in digging out the news and trends about the movement of jobs overseas and the accompanying smokescreen in the press. Her most recent post, Ross School of Outsourcing, is long but more than worthwhile to read. (This explains why she didn't post for five days, I'm thinking.)

The motivation for her post is a deconstruction of a Detroit News commentary by Robert (Bob) Kennedy, and Carrie does a fine job of going through it (and how she stomachs yet another variation on the offshoring is good, visas are better, American workers are unqualified and lousy, I can't imagine). Kennedy is a University of Michigan professor, something that apparently doesn't require the examination of multiple sides of an issue, especially as he is also the executive director of the William Davidson Institute. This is one of those ostensibly "non-profit, independent, research and educational institute[s]" that has been financed by an "international manufacturer of glass products."

It's not impossible that the WDI began as a place of legitimate inquiry, but it's oh-so-easy to look at who's writing the checks, an international manufacturer that employs a lot of overseas workers, and conclude that the development of a belief that offshoring is socially positive is a good career move. (Whether a public university should accept money to promote the beliefs of the donor under the aegis of the institution is a big issue, one for another day.)

I'm not going to even try to rehash Carrie's post, it's so dense (in a good way) that I couldn't do it justice, but I will follow one of her links, the one to Bob's blog. Actually, the blog isn't totally Bob's, there's another contributor named Lou LaFrate. He is not a staff member at WDI, he's a Director of Business Development in the automotive field. I don't know what company Lou works for, but I have my suspicions.

Anyway, this blog essentially exists as a promotional mechanism for Bob's new book. (To show you the incestuous nature of these matters, at least three of the nine Amazon reviews, which are all 5-star!!, are written by WDI staff - in other words, they work for Bob. Lou's got another, and a few are hard to tell.) You can find it on your own.

As Carrie says:
In an odd way, his site will make an excellent resource for anti-offshoring bloggers who might be looking for something to write about. Kennedy probably has the finest collection of links around that talk about the great benefits of offshoring, outsourcing, and how the loss of millions of manufacturing and higher-level service jobs in the U.S. will ultimately lead to greater prosperity for all.
And that's certainly true. Just catch this item (posted by Lou):
A story in the LA Times reported that employment in the region surrounding San Jose dropped 1.3% late last year. The key reason cited is the lack of "enough skilled workers needed to drive the next decade's innovation". This specific issue is addressed as one of the 5 key drivers of globalization in chapter two of Bob's book.
They captured the essence of the story correctly, then used it to frighten us with the news that students at the Indian School of Business "have chosen to opt for domestic offers over international offers." (The story is simplistic if it thinks the key reason for lower employment in a severe recession is a lack of skilled workers.) The whole blog is like this, that offshoring is not just inevitable (which may be true), but is desirable as well. If it were just another advocacy blog (like, quite often, my own), that would be fine. There's definitely a point of view, as the current political trend is described as:
more and more defensive posturing by politicians introducing “buy American” provisions in legislations, restricting H-1B visas, etc.
That this might not be "defensive posturing," but a principle that American money should go to support Americans, is not something Bob and Lou want to get into.

What is disturbing is that a university and its faculty are supposed to be seekers of the truth. They're supposed to look at all sides of the issue and try to find reality in it.

Bob, on the other hand, has made up his mind and is willing to cherry-pick facts to support his bought-and-paid-for notions. He's done well jumping on the offshoring wave, and he's going to ride it as long and hard as he can.

And mroe power to him. He can advocate offshoring while ignoring every argument that someone might present which points out possible deleterious long-term effects, and it will have no effect on his tenure, his large private consulting business to overseas and multinational corporations, his book sales.

It may just take the maturation of distance learning technology, in which his job is given to one of those Indian School of Business graduates who's staying home, to get Bob to question some of his assumptions. We can only hope.


Tuesday, March 10, 2009

OK, we're saved

I'm going to give President Obama some credit for taking on a whole bunch of challenges. A lot of people, particularly the talking heads on the Sunday talk shows, believe he's taking on too much, that he should focus like a laser on the economy and let everything else slide.

Here's what I believe: Obama sees where the country is and thinks pretty much everything has to change, that to do one thing without the other is doomed to failure. We can't fix the banking system without getting our whole financial system on firm footing, and we can't do that while Americans fear the crippling effects on having insufficient health care. And we have to stop spending so much on health care. We can't continue our dependency on other countries for energy, we have to bring that home, and, in so doing, we'll create new jobs. And so on, and so forth.

I certainly don't buy into every detail of these things, and I think the effects will be far less than forecast. There is an enduring optimism that people who have made the system work for them tend to have, and that's lovely; for those of us who have been buffeted about a little more, who have not had a meteoric rise to the Presidency, things do not look as rosy.

But I applaud the attempt to look at the nation as a holistic system, one that has to improve in several areas at once. If Obama took the standard approach of serializing these problems, the one that Congress seems to prefer, he would need five terms to accomplish everything.

There would also be inequities in this approach brought on by exigency. If we throw money at the banking system for 18 months to save it, bankers are going to receive all the perceived benefits of these actions. However, if we're improving health care at the same time, then everyone's getting something.

So, fine, let's take on education as well. I believe that Obama is captive to conventional wisdom on the subject, but any effort would be welcome, right? Let's see. He gave a major address on education to the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce this morning, and let's take a look at it.

He begins with a nice riff that talks about balancing the short-term with the long-term (along the lines I talked about above):
In the short term, that means jump-starting job creation and restarting lending, and restoring confidence in our markets and our financial system. But it also means taking steps that not only advance our recovery, but lay the foundation for lasting, shared prosperity.

I know there's some who believe we can only handle one challenge at a time. And they forget that Lincoln helped lay down the transcontinental railroad and passed the Homestead Act and created the National Academy of Sciences in the midst of civil war. Likewise, President Roosevelt didn't have the luxury of choosing between ending a depression and fighting a war; he had to do both. President Kennedy didn't have the luxury of choosing between civil rights and sending us to the moon. And we don't have the luxury of choosing between getting our economy moving now and rebuilding it over the long term.

America will not remain true to its highest ideals -- and America's place as a global economic leader will be put at risk -- unless we not only bring down the crushing cost of health care and transform the way we use energy, but also if we do -- if we don't do a far better job than we've been doing of educating our sons and daughters; unless we give them the knowledge and skills they need in this new and changing world.
There's the obligatory mention of how the GI Bill...investments in math and science...the wonders of Google..."economic progress and educational achievement have always gone hand in hand."

But then we run off the rails:
The source of America's prosperity has never been merely how ably we accumulate wealth, but how well we educate our people. This has never been more true than it is today. In a 21st-century world where jobs can be shipped wherever there's an Internet connection, where a child born in Dallas is now competing with a child in New Delhi, where your best job qualification is not what you do, but what you know -- education is no longer just a pathway to opportunity and success, it's a prerequisite for success.
This paragraph is more of the nonsense we've heard for years. The "what you do," "what you know" distinction is ludicrous, especially if you're in the market for a job and running up against the hirers who say that you need "exactly" the qualifications in the job description. When people start to pay for "what you know" rather than for job titles, we'll have something.

Worse, of course, is the perpetuation of the idea that the Dallas child is falling behind his Indian counterpart because of his remarkable stupidity and the incompetence of his teachers. How many more times do I (and many, though not enough, other commentators) have to stress that the jobs are lost not because of the awesome intellectual power of Dajit or Li-Xun, but because of the discrepancy in compensation. I know why Bill Gates pushes this idiocy, but I want to think better of Obama.

On he goes:
So let there be no doubt: The future belongs to the nation that best educates its citizens -- and my fellow Americans, we have everything we need to be that nation. We have the best universities, the most renowned scholars. We have innovative principals and passionate teachers and gifted students, and we have parents whose only priority is their child's education. We have a legacy of excellence, and an unwavering belief that our children should climb higher than we did.
But there is doubt. We have the "most renowned scholars," most of whom use whatever clout they've earned to stay as far away from the undergraduate classroom as possible. We have universities that get far more excited about March Madness than graduation rates for those athletes. And we have tuition rates that are skyrocketing even as opportunities for our young people are narrowing.
It's that most American of ideas, that with the right education, a child of any race, any faith, any station, can overcome whatever barriers stand in their way and fulfill their God-given potential.
This is a wonderful sentiment, really it is, but it conflicts with what we're actually seeing. This expression of the American Dream has run headlong into the other expression, that people should be free to exploit whatever resources they can in order to enrich themselves. If that means we treat the workforce as replacable drags on personal fortunes, so be it. If that means we use cheap foreign workers to line our own pockets, that's the American Dream for a whole lot of executives.

The next part of Obama's speech is very good, as he talks about "the same stale debates that have paralyzed progress and perpetuated our educational decline." That's all true, especially in Washington, which has managed to create No Child Left Behind, a set-it-and-forget-it system that brought laissez-faire thinking to education. And no one should be able to argue with:
The time for holding us -- holding ourselves accountable is here. What's required is not simply new investments, but new reforms. It's time to expect more from our students. It's time to start rewarding good teachers, stop making excuses for bad ones. It's time to demand results from government at every level.
Of course, he follows that with:
It's time to prepare every child, everywhere in America, to out-compete any worker, anywhere in the world. It's time to give all Americans a complete and competitive education from the cradle up through a career.
Again, until every American child is given the ability to live on $10,000 a year, this "out-compete" business is just an excuse. No one knows a way to make American children five or so times as productive as foreign children, so the numbers will never add up. Furthermore, we don't actually know what constitutes a "complete and competitive education" in our current situation.

Obama then moves into the five "pillars" of his program. The first is more support for early education. As someone who grew up pretty far right, this kind of program always strikes me as a but heavy-handed, asking government to intrude into the lives of people.

But then I think of teenagers having babies, the lack of reliable day care, the research that indicates that children learn an incredible amount before the age of 5, and I get a little more sympathetic to these efforts. There are still problems: if we can't find top quality teachers for the grades we have, where will we get the ones who are capable of teaching 3-year-olds?

The second pillar is to "spur a race to the top by encouraging better standards and assessments." Here's the thing, and I should probably put this at the end, but no one ever accused my posts of being organized.

Our schools should be better, not because of some vaguely-defined objectives about "competitiveness" or "economic decline," because we still haven't defined the way the one translates into the other - the forces that are creating economic decline have surprisingly little to do with education. No, they should be better in the way that anything we take on should be better. If we're going to spend billions on education, we simply should take enough pride in ourselves to do it more effectively. If other nations are really doing a better job of teaching their kids, that's just wrong.

Obama wants "tougher, clearer standards," and that's fine. Of course, he's calling on states to make that happen, which is somewhat contradictory. If we're to have one set of standards for the nation, they'll have to come from one place...and that place will be Washington. Politics will determine if that's going to happen.

This part, however:
I'm calling on our nation's governors and state education chiefs to develop standards and assessments that don't simply measure whether students can fill in a bubble on a test, but whether they possess 21st century skills like problem-solving and critical thinking and entrepreneurship and creativity.
irks me, because there is no real proof that we can teach those things effectively. If we can't even teach bubble-filling, how do we teach creativity? We don't know, so it will be back to the same experimentation that has been the hallmark of American education for decades - the same decades that have demonstrated our decline.

The third pillar is probably the most problematic. It's the need for:
recruiting, preparing, and rewarding outstanding teachers.
Need I point out, again, that the probability of creating 3,000,000 great teachers is highly unlikely. I commend Obama for putting money into local government so we don't see layoffs in our schools, because fewer teachers can't be the answer. And urging young people to go into education is never a bad thing (other than the philosophical dilemma, do we really want our best and brightest to teach instead of do?).

And here we come to the magic, that marvelous word "accountability," which automatically makes the weak strong. The usual stuff here from the President, mentoring, merit pay, guidance, support.

But the carrot doesn't come without the stick. We're going to get those bad teachers out of the classroom, drum them right out.

[Then there's this:
I reject a system that rewards failure and protects a person from its consequences. The stakes are too high. We can afford nothing but the best when it comes to our children's teachers and the schools where they teach.
If only Mr. Obama had the same standards for bankers and auto executives....]

I'm sure I've said this before, but there's a level of unreality here. We really don't know how to evaluate teachers, to distinguish great from good from OK from salvageable from irredeemable. If you're an administrator in a marginal school district, there's a huge incentive to keep the bodies you have. You don't know where the next crop is coming from, and you sure don't know they'll be any better, so you tend to inflate the grades so at least you aren't showing the newbies where the cafeteria is.

The fourth pillar is, of course, "promoting innovation and excellence in America's schools." How do we do this? Charter schools, accountability, blah, blah, blah.

There's an inconsistency here. We're going to couple accountability with autonomy; add those to higher standards imposed from outside, and you have oxymoronic thinking. We can't let charter schools, for which the evidence of effectiveness is actually pretty thin, go off and do their own things at the same time we make them more accountable. It makes no sense at all, we have to choose one or the other.

The longer school year, the talk of individual responsibility, I'm certainly all for that, but Obama is trying to use his popularity to change behavior. Good luck with that. Of course kids shouldn't drop out, but the tie between these policies and the high rate in some places is tenuous at best.

Pillar five is "a quality higher education." Simplifying forms and raising Pell Grants are good things, but drops in the bucket. Something that will get attention is Obama's exhortation for each American to "commit to at least one year or more of higher education or career training,
with the goal of having the highest proportion of college graduates in
the world by the year 2020."

This is fine, I suppose, but even Obama says:
By 2016, four out of every 10 new jobs will require at least some advanced education or training.
I don't really see how these things go together. 60% of new jobs will not require this training, so why are we putting every student on the track of more education? Yes, Obama includes technical training along with college, but the emphasis is clearly on colleges and universities.

Interestingly enough, government will be the solution through programs and funding. I'm not seeing the place where we ask business to step up and do anything, even if they are the ones profiting.

So, unfortunately, there is very little new here. There is no recognition that job loss comes from anything other than our incompetence vis-à-vis other countries, that we need to create alternate tracks for students who won't master the world economy, that we have any idea of matching supply to demand.

No, it's the usual ideas supporting the concept that all education is good, more is better, and we should move heaven and earth to get it. There was nothing about the disconnect between the people who already did that and are finding themselves passed by, and the promise to our nation's children that this is likely to increase. Sadly, this speech is the standard, let's do all this good stuff and magic will happen. I'd like to see some more creative thinking than that.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Darn, she got there first - Microsoft edition

One of the challenges in trying to produce something novel every day (as opposed to the bloggers who churn out tens of rip-n-point posts) is that smart people tend to plow the same ground, and they're often quicker than I. Citizen Carrie has done that to me again in her work the past few days on the two big Microsoft stories.

First, she used the overpayment to laid-off Microsoft workers as a springboard to a discussion of outsourcing. There's a lot here, but the big takeaway is just how much offshoring is done under the radar. As I've written before, there is no official count of just which jobs and how many are being sent overseas, which leaves the question open enough that opinions end up carrying the day. The business apologists contend that the issue is overstated, that few jobs are in fact moving. After all, there are no numbers to back it up. (Personally, as someone in one of the major offshoring job categories, I think there's plenty of it, and more to come.)

Carrie also has this:
If you ever want to know what it's like being the low person on the totem pole, try working in the unglamourous fields of finance, accounting, payroll, human resources, legal compliance, etc., (heck, might as well add IT) in most corporations. These employees are scorned for not adding direct value to an organization and are treated as nothing more than parasites draining away profits. Instead of being treated as valuable team members, they are treated as being people who are ripe for outsourcing to the BPO company that comes in and gives the niftiest PowerPoint presentation.
2Truthy had a comment that HR folks "tend to have the loftier roles in companies." It turns out they're both right. The lower-down people, those who administer benefits and do pre-interview screening, tend to be, just as Carrie says, down in the pits with all the other outsourceable people. I've seen a big evolution there in the IT world, where, in many companies, there are no HR people at all. Hiring managers have had to add base-level resume screening to their repertoire of talents.

On the other hand, 2Truthy is right in that the top HR people are thought of as massively important. After all, we can't expect a CEO to deal directly with the outside search company that's been hired to conduct a "nationwide" hunt for the next CFO. Very often, an executive who's being groomed for bigger things is given a top role in HR so he or she can get an overview of the company.

Of course, this just makes the gulf between management and the rank and file wider, but this is necessary if the big guys are going to be able to make the tough decisions. Only by dehumanizing the employees can the non-sociopaths in the executive suite (there are a few) handle the rampant destruction they cause.

[Carrie also links to the recent Friedman column that talks up innovation. In his typical fashion, he issues pronouncements without having to consider reality. Essentially, the government should go into the venture capital business and, when the new-energy version of Microsoft or Intel hits, we the people will make 80% of the returns.

This sounds somewhat compelling, but fails to talk about the end game. Does the government retain that stake on into the future, thus nationalizing the energy industry, or do we miss out on the greatest returns?

Friedman also returns to the curious point that he has been pushing, that we should strive to produce this new energy at the lowest price possible, his so-called ChinIndia price. That it is not the goal of an American country to provide low-cost energy to the world, not if there is a higher-cost point that leads to greater profits, never occurs to our happy pundit.]

Carrie also has a post about Microsoft's other great announcement, their "Elevate America" project. As Carrie puts it:
[T]hey will take the few remaining people in the U.S. who don't know how to type up resumes, much less send them off as email attachments, and educate them into crackerjack, top-notch Microsoft Certified professionals.
I plan to keep my eye on this, but what has been presented so far does not overwhelm. There are four sections at the link, three of which are essentially ads for training programs. The one free part features five courses, each taking 2-3 hours, and they essentially constitute Computing for Dummies.

This kind of thing may be helpful for a very few people, but it's hard to believe that any of this will lead to a way upwards for our economically downtrodden. I'm guessing that the vast majority of the people who can read this blog will pass the "Digital Literacy Certificate Test" without cracking a course.

Still, I'm not an anti-Microsoft person (nor am I a zealot for them as are so many). They have a great number of resources for developers on the Internet, and it's possible that Elevate America will evolve into something useful. At the same time, let's not, for example, ramp up the H-1Bs just because MS has a program with the word "America" in the name.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Textbook prices

I'm not trying to pick on Kevin Drum; it's actually a measure of my respect for him that I read him so closely (he was, perhaps, the first political/economic blogger I read regularly). In general, we have similar views on things, and from what he has written, our backgrounds are not so different.

He posed a question yesterday that he spent too little time thinking about. He's wondering why textbooks are so expensive, even comparing one of his from 1976 to the current price, finding that it's more than doubled in real dollars. The book is, apparently, pretty much identical to the 33-year-old version:

This, then, is obviously a book that ought to be cheaper today than it was three decades ago. The costs of production have long since been paid back, there's a ton of competition from the used book market since the book hasn't changed in 30 years, and I imagine that author royalties are the same as ever. For reference, a similar size commercial hardback would run about $40 these days.

So what is the deal? Why are textbooks such a ripoff?

Drum points us to the Andrew Gelman post that got the topic started, and to Henry Farrell's effort. Farrell takes us a little closer to some part of the truth as he mentions the "captive market" of students, who are pretty much at the mercy of whatever whim the professor uses to make a choice.

But none of the three mention the larger reason, that book publishers are under the same pressures to bloat profits as any other company. In many cases, they have become subsidiaries of conglomerates, and the book publishing division is as much on the hook as is any other corporate piece. They see a monopoly situation, they're pretty much bound to jump on it and milk it for all it's worth.

Add to that the low profit margins found in their overseas markets. In India, textbooks that are identical except for some cover art and the binding cost maybe a tenth of what they cost here. Much like the prescription drug market, the book publishers are going to get their money somehow. If they can't get it at the Indian Institute of Technology, they're going to get it by soaking the "rich kids" of America. We, in effect, are subsidizing the foreign textbook market.

So it is no wonder that textbooks cost so much - they're being used to advance social objectives that have nothing to do with educating American students. They are a hidden form of foreign aid.

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Great comments

My Saturday post on education has generated a couple of great comments, and I thought, if you're not a thread-follower, you might like seeing them on the main blog. So here they are, along with my modest effort in between. First, from Citizen Carrie:
Lots of food for thought here. I'm kind of partial to City College and State U, and I tend to equate University of Phoenix with the old-fashioned diploma mills. I guess my biggest problem is I don't know any University of Phoenix graduates. I know a lot of people taking classes, but it's too early to judge whether their schooling is doing their careers any good. The few people I (barely) knew who did graduate usually left the companies right away for supposedly greener pastures elsewhere, and then I lost track of them.

I'm actually kind of surprised that the University of Phoenix model appears to be somewhat sucessful because, at least where I live, even the big-name colleges have very good study programs for non-traditional students. I really credit the U of P marketing campaigns for being wildly successful in attracting students. I briefly ran a company's tuition reimbursement program several years ago and, through my unrepresentative random sampling, found that our employees didn't even seem to realize that tuition at University of Phoenix was more expensive then at public universities!

I also think that a lot of the people who defaulted on their U of P loans might also have defaulted no matter where they attended school. Through their marketing campaigns, U of P could be attracting students who might otherwise not consider continuing their education, and they might not be, shall we say, well-suited for these programs.

I haven't personally seen anything to suggest that the University of Phoenix does a poor job of instructing their students, at least in lower level classes. I also don't have a problem with for-profit educational institutions, as long as they can deliver the goods and give people a better shot at landing a better-paying job after graduation. I know of several smaller, less-prestigious schools that, in many instances, better prepare their students for employment than the more prestigious colleges. But a fine education from experienced instructors won't do you any good if employers look at your resume to see what college you attended and start laughing.
From me:
Interesting comments, Carrie, and I appreciate them.

One thought I had: perhaps the massive education budget of some of these for-profit places has as much to do with establishing a reputation among employers as it does in attracting students. After all, if you've just dropped a few hundred bucks attending an NFL game in University of Phoenix Stadium, maybe you won't be as tempted to laugh when you get back to the office on Monday and pick up a resume from a graduate of U of P.
And from Greg Glockner:
Wow, where to start.

First, I'm amused whenever I open my email spam folder and see all the ads for "buy a Ph.D.". I always laugh because I've already got one! (No kidding!)

Now, when I was studying to become Piled Higher and Deeper, I was a TA (by my own choice), and it was a painful education - for me! The lessons I learned were that the students - at the #1 ranked program for my branch of engineering - expected good grades, no matter how poor or fraudulent their work. In other words, I had students who had so blatantly cheated on their work - violating the school's honor code - and they still believed they were entitled to a good grade.

I remember a particular high school math teacher who once taught me that you don't deserve "partial credit" for a wrong answer - because wrong answers can cause markets to crash, planes to crash and bridges to fail. The harsh truth is unpopular.

That said, I think part of the problem is the ridiculous expectations for university education in America. A liberal arts education is great for the minority of students who are motivated by a love of knowledge. But why did this become de rigueur for the population at large? And why is there such stigma with a vocational education? I see no shame in a career in sales, healthcare, product repair. Do these careers require familiarity with literature and history? No, their success requires mastery of computers, communications, marketing and other practical skills that are seldom taught in college.

I have nothing wrong with American higher education; I just don't think it's the right path for many people who are guided to follow it.
As for Greg's comment, I will mayhap have more to say later, but one side observation I will make is that, in some fields, even the "right" answer isn't right. For an interesting post by Daniel Little which talks about this in economics, see Mark Thoma's reference from 12/29/08 (and the comments are interesting too). There's some good stuff there about correctness and completeness, and I urge you to read it.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Journey to the West

As I said upon returning, I will now offer up some observations on California after my short sojourn last week. These may not be incredibly profound, but they're all I have.

1) I spent some time with people who came to this country in the 1970s from the Republic of China (which I will now call Taiwan since that's how we in the U.S. see it). Some of these folks have been remarkably successful, others less so, but right down the line their children are doing well.

[This is probably a good place to stop and point out that I understand the dangers of generalization, something I will be doing throughout this essay. I believe my observations have some validity, but I know that is a far cry from universality. Nevertheless....]

What struck me was that the degrees of separation hypothesis (that almost everyone on Earth is connected to everyone else by no more than six steps) needs a smaller number among this population. The people at the table seemed to have no more than two degrees to the new president, Ma Ying-Jeou, which seems surprising until you realize that there were a very small number of top schools that generated most of the immigrants at that time, and the ones who went back after studying here are part of that group.

But that demonstrates, I think, the two fallacies we have about immigrants and, now, foreigners. For we believe, based on what we've seen, that the Chinese and Indians and others who come here are the best and brightest (which they tend to be based on selection), then we extend that to (1st myth) believing that any further immigrants would be equally talented or entrepreneurial, then, in a huge stretch, (2nd myth) that the people who remain in their countries are also equally talented, that it's something genetic.

Here's the deal. The people who have come here to go to school tend to already be the best and the brightest, from good disciplined families - they simply are not reflective of the overall population of those countries (any more than the graduating class of Harvard is reflective of America's 22-year-olds). Even then, many of that first generation don't do as well as they would like (or, possibly, as well as if they had gone back). So when we set immigration and offshoring policies based on the "magical" qualities of Indians or Chinese or Koreans, we need to understand that we're looking for evidence from an already-select group.

2) A lot is made of the laid-back quality of Californians. When I left Chicago, it was below zero. When I got to San Jose, it was over 70 degrees.

My sense is that Californians have the luxury of being more experiential than the rest of us; that is, every day is something of a reward and they know it. If you live in other areas of the country, many days do not contain that intrinsic satisfaction, so we end up being more goal-oriented. For us, it's getting to something or somewhere else, because we don't get 365 days a year to enjoy the world. We have a grimmer focus on hitting the high points because our day-to-day lives offer less of the simple sensory enjoyment that is a near-daily occurrence to the Californian.

[Note: in reading this point over, it seems a bit pretentious, bordering on the David Brooks. Nonetheless, I'll leave it, because it was a thought I had out there, and that's what I promised to my readers.]

3) The economic news from California is pretty grim, with the unemployment rate hitting 9.3%. There is speculation, at least from one writer in the San Jose Mercury News, that California may be a "rust-belt-to-be":

Defense spending in the 1980s, high-tech startups in the 1990s and housing-fueled consumer spending in the 1990s — all were California economic bubbles that burst spectacularly, leaving recession and government deficits in their wake.

What, if anything, will come next to pull us out of recession and return California to prosperity? Some think it will be biotechnology, services to baby boomer retirees or solving global warming.

Lurking in the background, however, is a nagging worry that there won't be anything, that the state's endemically high costs, political dysfunction and long list of unresolved dilemmas, from transportation to water to education, have made us uncompetitive in a global economy. Just last week, a new federal survey found that California has the nation's highest adult illiteracy rate.

We have tended to take the future for granted. No matter how moribund the economy may be at the moment, we think, we have the weather, the entrepreneurial spirit and the strategic location to regroup and prosper.

We may have. But then again, maybe we aren't so special. Maybe we're not immune to the societal afflictions that have beset other states. Maybe we are a rust-belt-to-be on the left coast, a Michigan with winter sunshine.

I'm no expert on what's going on out there, but it seems clear that there are major problems ahead for our most populous state. What does this do to the theory that all we have to do is accumulate enough good minds in one place and wonderful things will happen? Because that's the prevailing theory that we're applying to educational policy, that we can just educate all the youngsters and our needs will be met, innovation will happen, and the streets will run with milk and honey.

There are some remarkable conditions in the Golden State, including some of the best institutions of higher learning and an environment which attracts the best from all over the world, but that isn't proving sufficient to overcome all the many things that seem to be getting in the way. There are so many things that contribute to the success of an area, a state, a nation, a world, and, while I would never deny that rising levels of education is desirable, it doesn't seem that assembling a critical mass of bright people is quite enough.

Saturday, January 24, 2009

Education for fun and profit - Part 2

In Part 1 yesterday, I used a Matt Yglesias post to speak to the changes that are coming to the relationship of people to institutions of higher education. I argued that the conversion from a complex relationship to a simpler transaction-based model will have rather big effects. Yglesias stated that for-profit colleges are somehow "obliged" to rip off their students in any way possible, which seems like overstatement, but it is valid, I think, to contend that people are going to look at their education in starkly different ways and have higher expectations of what it will do for their lives.

Yglesias goes on:
[T]he nature of the higher education market is such that there’s no way these for-profits can ever be anything other than low-end options.
He doesn't really back that up at all, except by implying that the managers of for-profit colleges have that incentive to "screw you over." Contrast that with the model we have in our not-for-profit research institutions, where undergraduates pay rather large bucks to be taught by poorly-paid TAs, supporting a large R&D facility that is unlikely to have a great effect on their instruction in Beginning Microeconomics. Good luck, young folks, in even getting to see one of the Nobel laureates who is getting major money and incentives to come write their papers and do their experiments (one of those incentives being the opportunity not to teach an undergraduate course).

Yglesias does seem to get that, though this particular post doesn't explicate that well, as he often talks about his unwillingness to give money to his institution of higher learning, Harvard University, because they already have so much, and any contributions could be applied more usefully elsewhere. [I actually agree with this stand, but there is a slight incongruity in that his Harvard affiliation seems to come up quite frequently, an ongoing benefit for which, I guess, he feels he's already paid - or, perhaps, he may feel his current prestige is a plus for Harvard.]

He also writes:
I think the main lesson here is that traditional universities need to do a better job of getting into the niche that’s currently dominated by these poorly performing for-profits. In part, state governments would do well to shift emphasis away from trying to burnish the sheen on their “flagship” traditional universities and toward doing more in the way of providing community college services for working and non-traditional students.
In other words, state university systems need to get more vocational; they need to look at their competition as being the likes of University of Phoenix and not Harvard. They need to respond to the needs of their consumers, presumably through less research and more teaching, flexible hours, perhaps a bigger on-line presence, and so forth.

I can barely sort out the conundra here. First, don't we like, in general, to leave the consumer-responsive aspects of a business to the market? Aren't the for-profits far better positioned to react to the needs of market demand than a governmental agency? Anyone who has watched the tortured attempts of the University of Illinois to develop an on-line program knows exactly what I'm talking about.

Of course, the risk is that we'll find out just how little the market is for some programs and specialties. When we start seeing the new consumer-responsive state colleges dropping history because there just isn't a market for it, how will that go over?

Second, do we really trust the private college system to be able to do all the things we now want a public system to do? If the state colleges move more toward providing "community college services," then all the people who now need the subsidies currently in the public system will have to go to the private system, and they may well not be able to afford it. One could argue that the private system will adjust to those new realities, but that seems more a hope than a plan.

Finally, we hear so much about training students for the needs of the 21st century workplace. I have sincere doubts that this really constitutes a proper strategy, as I've expressed before, but let's take it at face value and assume that we have a consensus, that we need more computer scientists and engineers and mathematicians and so on.

Where will they come from? Yglesias has the public system "dropping down" to meet immediate market needs for "working and non-traditional students," in effect crowding the space of the for-profit and community colleges. Yet we need the highly-trained, highly-developed graduates of the best programs in order to create Tom Friedman's free electrons and the New Energy economy which will enrich us all.

I know that a coherent world view will always be in conflict with what seems to be relatively easy solutions to problems. But I guess I expect more second- and third-order thinking from some people. My ongoing frustrations with Yglesias (who is, after all, the 16th-most influential liberal in the U.S. media) is that, I believe, he writes so much that he tends to dash off thoughts without developing them. It really shouldn't be all that difficult to work through some of the implications of changing the mission of the public education system, especially when you're using that as a way of getting rid of the for-profit institutions that clearly are filling some kind of niche, no matter how incompetently.

And I respect him enough that I'd like to hear his thoughts on that, see his logic. Instead, I just get a blanket statement that, as written, seems fairly unpersuasive.

Friday, January 23, 2009

Education for fun and profit - Part 1

Occasionally a post comes along that stokes more than one reaction; one such is Yglesias from yesterday, a post called Making Money in Higher Education. In it, he comments on a post from Kevin Carey that takes for-profit college University of Phoenix to task for funny business with student loans, then says more generally:
I'm not among those who think that for-profit colleges and universities are necessarily bad. It's a free country and some institutions have put together a package of services that students want to buy. For-profits often seem to be focused on meeting the needs of their customers, particularly working and non-traditional students, in ways that traditional non-profits do not. But they also tend to be expensive and highly dependent on students borrowing a great deal of money to attend. Dropout rates at for-profits are often quite high. And if more than a quarter or a third of your students are defaulting on their loans within a few years of leaving, then pretty much by definition they weren't getting a sufficiently valuable service in exchange for their money.
Yglesias amplifies on this, as he is suspicious of for-profit education, saying this:
The managers of a traditional university may or may not take and opportunity to screw over their students for money, but the managers of a for-profit are obliged to screw you over. That could be counteracted by a desire to build a good reputation, but the nature of the higher education market is such that there’s no way these for-profits can ever be anything other than low-end options.
As I've said before, I don't generally read other people's comments until after I've written a post. This time I've made an exception, because I wasn't originally planning to write about this. But a lot of commenters are going back and forth on the "obliged" part, most against.

I think I get what Yglesias is trying to say here, but I don't think I ought to be required to interpret his words. He's essentially, in an inartful manner, expressing the view that all exchanges in an economy need to be win-win, that is, each party feels they're getting more value than they're giving. The students at U of Phoenix or anywhere else pony up their bucks, but that leads to a larger revenue stream down the road. The university makes money for shareholders by ensuring that the bucks paid cover the costs, with enough left over to pay executive salaries and add to stock price. (I think Yglesias is saying that the for-profit model obliges university executives to provide as little premium as possible, that is, they don't give away anything, and the students believe that there is still value-added...I think.)

Of course, there is an inherent uncertainty to the value a student gains, and a precise dollar figure isn't able to be calculated until long after the fact (OK, I know it can never be, but a whole lot of people "credit" their college with making them who they are). At the same time, the university has a short-term focus on raking it in NOW, so they do have a powerful incentive to magnify a student's potential gains and work the costs to the absolute margins.

And this is why the model is so new, and still being worked out. Because, in the past (as I return to a familiar theme of mine), the emphasis was on building a relationship, and markets and economic analysis deal very poorly with those things. The student was becoming a part of a community, one which continued to give back in certain ways, even beyond the intrinsic value of the education itself, and he or she was expected to contribute to that community through donations or buying merchandise or what have you. It was pretty much impossible to calculate the pros and cons of such a relationship, so it became more of an emotional response - if you "felt" that Siwash U had made your life better, going there was worth it.

Now, and it's not just because there are for-profit universities, that has changed for a lot of people. It's now a colder calculation, what's in it for me? That rationality implies a quicker payback is needed, that any student is going to have to see more than just a promise of an improved life - as Carey says, if a large number of students are defaulting on their loans, they aren't going to see that as a personal weakness undermining the obviously-great education they received, they're going to see the education as somehow deficient. That changes the relationship from, "Hail, hail, to old State U," to, "I want my money." This has huge implications for the way we do higher education, a topic I'll elaborate on in Part 2.

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Another thought on teachers

I've thought a little more about yesterday's post on teaching, and there's another point I don't want to miss. I may have made it before, but I don't think I'll go back and plow through a year's worth of posts to see.

We all want every student to have great teachers at every grade level, in every class. We rarely define "great teacher," many contending that we know one when we see it. But that's reductive and unhelpful. Some want to define "great" as anyone who raises test scores by a certain amount, but that method is fraught with evaluation problems (as I discussed yesterday).

I know I have written before about the problem of making any profession that requires 3,000,000 members have only great ones; it's hard to see how anybody could find that many great anythings, let alone a job so multifaceted and complex as teaching.

But here's another thing: I've gone to school for many years, and I would say I've only had two great teachers. By that, I mean teachers who were inspirational and changed the way I saw my place in the world. I've had a whole lot of good teachers, people who competently stood in front of a classroom and conveyed information, and way too many bad teachers.

I spent a year as a substitute teacher in a nationally-respected high school, and got to see first-hand how disappointing a lot of the teachers were in terms of commitment and subject matter knowledge. One in particular struck me as remarkably poor; she spent all her free periods smoking in the teachers' lounge (back in the days when you could do that), never stayed late, and seemed to have no interest in mathematics at all.

However, a few years ago, I found a web site with teacher evaluations. Out of curiosity, I looked up this teacher, and found quite a bit of praise from her students. Some of them found her clear in teaching and inspirational in tone. Were they wrong? Was I wrong?

No to both questions. Teachers don't just teach in some value-neutral setting, they interact with hundreds of students a year. Every one of those interactions is conditioned by a student's prior experiences, their own maturity, the style of the teaching, and a whole lot of other factors. A teacher with none of the attributes I looked for might well fit another student perfectly. For me, office hours were important, because I often would go to kick around an idea, and I expected a great teacher to be there most of the time (if the schedule called for it). But if you were a student who confined their interaction to class time, other considerations became paramount.

I guarantee it goes the other way as well. Both of my "great teachers" were demanding, made us work hard, and I know that a lot of my fellow students would not have rated them as highly as I did. And neither of these gentlemen ever would have "taught to the test," so, if you were to measure them by either students reached (at that time; I would bet that a lot of the negative students have since come to realize the value those teachers provided) or by incremental test scores, they might well come up short and be forced to leave. (I'm also not at all sure how you measure the value added of a music teacher, which presents a real problem for all of the non-core subject teachers out there.) And, were that true, I might have had no great teachers in my life at all.

(Which brings up another big objection to the test score value-added method of evaluation: It tends to reward teachers who are good at bringing the poor student up to adequate over the teacher who is good at reaching the already-bright. If you have a talent for helping the 80 or 90 get to 100, you will come up far short of the teacher who gets the 10 up to 50. But we need both kinds of teachers, particularly if we want to use our "new schools" to jump-start our new advanced economy - all the 50s in the world aren't going to do much about that, we need the 100 students to be at the top of their game to create the technological future - but this is not the day for me to lament the hideous inadequacy of our gifted education.)
Clicky Web Analytics